2,312 court cases with AI-invented rulings: who falls for it and what it costs

A public database now counts 2,312 court decisions in which AI-fabricated rulings or quotes were spotted. We crunched the numbers: more than half the cases involve laypeople, but judges and government agencies fall into the trap too. Penalties are getting tougher, up to the first ban at the European Court of Human Rights. Germany shows up in the database surprisingly rarely.

Analysis Nov 19, 2026 11 min read Original analysis by our editors
Illustrative image, AI-generated

What's going on

Language models like ChatGPT “hallucinate”: they make up things that sound plausible but aren't true. In court, that gets especially embarrassing when filings cite rulings that never existed. Legal scholar Damien Charlotin of HEC Paris has been collecting such cases in his public database AI Hallucination Cases since spring 2025. As of November 18, 2026, it lists 2,312 decisions. A case only makes the list if a court explicitly or recognizably finds that someone relied on fabricated content. A mere accusation isn't enough.

We analyzed the database's filter counts and its German entries, and checked them against the court decisions and legal reporting. We focused on three questions: Who falls for the AI? How harsh are the penalties? And why does Germany show up so rarely?

Who trusts the AI: mostly laypeople, but not only

Who filed Entries Share
Laypeople without a lawyer (“pro se”) 1,326 57.4%
Lawyers 920 39.8%
Judges 34 1.5%
Expert witnesses 18 0.8%
Prosecutors 5 –
Government lawyers 3 –
Other (paralegals, public defenders, arbitrators) 5 –

Source: database filter counts as of Nov. 18, 2026; shares calculated by us.

So a good 57 percent of cases trace back to people representing themselves without a lawyer. According to Charlotin, they mostly use free models. Even so, nearly 40 percent of entries involve professionals. Also notable: in at least 43 cases, the errors came from the state or the judiciary.

A recent example comes from India. On November 17, 2026, the High Court of Madhya Pradesh (Justice Vivek Kumar Singh) reprimanded the state government, as Bar & Bench reports. In its reply in Piyush Mani Tiwari vs. State of Madhya Pradesh, the state had cited a Supreme Court ruling, “State of Andhra Pradesh vs. S.S. Mohammad Nisar, (2008) 5 SCC 230.” That ruling doesn't exist. The citation points to a decision on an entirely different matter: the suspension of a sentence in the Manu Sharma case. The court described the conduct as “bordering on actively misleading the court.” It sent the judgment to the state's law department and the Advocate General, and ruled in favor of the dismissed police officer who had brought the case. No fine was imposed.

Judges are affected too. In the US in 2025, federal judges Julien Neals (New Jersey) and Henry Wingate (Mississippi) withdrew rulings containing fabricated quotes. Both later said an intern or a staff member, respectively, had used generative AI. Senator Chuck Grassley then demanded an explanation.

The growth: explosive, recently a bit slower

According to eDiscovery Today, as of early July 2026 the database held only 16 cases for 2023 and just 59 for 2024. For 2025 there were 827, and the first half of 2026 had already surpassed that with 828. The snapshots regularly recorded by provider HAQQ paint this picture:

Period New entries Per day
May 22 – June 9, 2026 140 approx. 7.8
June 9 – Sept. 21, 2026 448 approx. 4.3
Sept. 21 – Oct. 19, 2026 156 approx. 5.6
Oct. 19 – Nov. 18, 2026 110 approx. 3.7

Last row calculated by us from the current count of 2,312.

That makes 266 new cases since September 21. In September, Charlotin told the Daily Caller that the numbers first rose exponentially and have now plateaued. He attributes this to better tools and greater awareness. Our take: the number of new entries also measures how much a single researcher can find and log. You can't reliably conclude from it that there are actually fewer cases.

From $5,000 to a practice ban: penalties are ramping up

Case Court, date Consequence
Mata v. Avianca US District Court, 2023 $5,000
Coomer v. Lindell US District Court, 2025 $3,000 each for two lawyers
Ayinde v Haringey High Court London, 2025 Referral to the regulator
Whiting v. City of Athens Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals, March 2026 $30,000 plus attorney's fees and double costs
Couvrette v. Wisnovsky District of Oregon, 2026 around $110,000 including costs
Withers v. City of Aberdeen District court, Mississippi, June 2026 Trial canceled, two lawyers barred from the district for two years, fines of $1,000 to $3,500 each
Romanian lawyer ECtHR, Nov. 13, 2026 Two-year ban on representation

According to EDRM, US courts imposed at least $145,000 in sanctions in the first quarter of 2026 alone. Trial-court fines mostly stayed below $10,000, while appellate courts are cracking down harder. Reports on the Oregon amount vary. EDRM cites a $15,500 sanction against the lead attorney; the roughly $110,000 figure only comes together once costs are added.

What's new is the decision from Strasbourg. According to Anadolu and Scottish Legal News, an ECtHR chamber found multiple errors in a Romanian lawyer's filings: nonexistent rulings, invented paragraphs in real decisions, and case law that contradicted her own arguments. The lawyer admitted using AI and spoke of “inaccuracies” and “citation errors.” The chamber, however, saw

“a recurring pattern of substantial errors rather than isolated oversights.”

Some references hadn't been checked at all, even though verifying them against the court's HUDOC database would have been easy. The court's president confirmed the ban on November 13 under Rule 44D of the Rules of Court, which governs the exclusion of representatives. According to ua.news, it was the first time the rule had been applied. We couldn't find a press release from the court on this, so that detail rests on a single source. The ban applies only to this lawyer and can be lifted under the rules. The reports don't name the lawyer or the case.

Our take: internationally, a two-year exclusion is no longer unprecedented, since the Mississippi court imposed the same in Withers back in June. What's new is that an international court is cracking down this hard for the first time, and that the ban covers an entire court where lawyers from 46 countries appear.

Germany: 11 entries, and the most important ones are missing

Germany has exactly 11 entries in the database. Looking through them, three turn out to be duplicates. That leaves eight actual proceedings, all from 2025:

Court, case number Who Consequence
Celle Higher Regional Court (OLG), 5 U 1/25 (Apr. 29, 2025) Lawyer Citations disregarded
Cologne Local Court (AG), 312 F 130/25 (July 2, 2025) Lawyer Reference to Section 43a(3) BRAO
Baden-Württemberg Higher Administrative Court (VGH), 3 S 1012/25 (July 8, 2025) Lawyer None
Berlin Court of Appeal (KG), 3 ORbs 164/25 (Aug. 25, 2025) Lawyer Appeal on points of law rejected, conduct “questionable”
Frankfurt Regional Court (LG), 2-13 S 56/24 (Sept. 25, 2025) Lawyer Public reprimand (“a complete fabrication”)
Darmstadt Regional Court (LG), 19 O 527/16 (Nov. 10, 2025) Expert witness Fee cut to zero
Cologne Administrative Court (VG), 4 L 3030/25 (Nov. 14, 2025) Layperson None
Berlin Court of Appeal (KG), 17 WF 144/25 (Nov. 20, 2025) Lawyer Warning

Two more recent decisions are missing entirely. On September 30, 2026, the Federal Labour Court (BAG) rejected a complaint against denial of leave to appeal as inadmissible (case no. 2 AZN 339/26, not 339/25). Such a complaint asks a higher court to take up a case in the first place. According to Haufe, the brief contained “a whole series” of hallucinated citations, had no law firm letterhead, and was formatted in bold and underlined throughout. The BAG concluded that the lawyer had neither written nor reviewed the text himself. That meant the mandatory representation by a lawyer before the BAG (Section 11(4) ArbGG) was missing, and the client lost. On September 23, 2026, the Bavarian Constitutional Court (BayVerfGH, Vf. 9-VI-25) dismissed the constitutional complaint of a father who apparently had no lawyer. He had cited supposed principles of the court itself that don't exist, “probably due to the use of so-called hallucinating AI.” The father has to pay the maximum fee of €3,000. According to beck-aktuell, though, it's unclear whether the fee was imposed specifically because of the AI citations.

Per capita, the gap is large. Using rounded population figures, the US comes in at about 4.6 entries per million inhabitants, Canada at 6.0, Israel at 5.9 and Australia at 4.1. Germany sits at 0.13, France at 0.2 and Italy at 0.25. So the dividing line isn't between countries with and without mandatory legal representation. It runs between Anglo-American case law (common law), where precedents are the main argument, and continental European statutory law.

Mandatory representation, or looking the other way?

One detail supports the mandatory-representation explanation: in Germany, six of the eight proceedings involve lawyers, whereas laypeople dominate worldwide. Before regional courts, higher regional courts and federal courts, laypeople can't file on their own at all. The BAG case shows how a layperson's text can still slip through: the defendant suspected that the plaintiff's husband had written the complaint with AI.

Visibility probably matters more, though. According to a study by Hanjo Hamann (JuristenZeitung 2021), no more than about 1 percent of court decisions in Germany were published in any given year. If a local court warns a layperson about a fabricated citation, as a rule nobody ever hears about it. Charlotin himself says he only records decisions he finds. The fact that the BAG and BayVerfGH rulings are missing, even though beck-aktuell, Haufe and the Federal Bar (BRAK) reported on them, suggests that German sources are simply less well covered. There's also a substantive reason: German courts are required to know and apply the law themselves. A fabricated citation is then often quietly ignored, as the Celle court did, rather than addressed in a separate ruling.

Why German courts only issue warnings

Our take: the tool simply isn't there. US courts can fine lawyers directly under their procedural rules, and British courts can order lawyers to pay costs personally. German civil courts have no comparable instrument. Professional oversight rests with the bar associations, and courts can only point to the issue, as the Cologne Local Court did by citing the duty of objectivity in Section 43a(3) BRAO (Federal Lawyers' Act). We found no publicly documented disciplinary proceedings by a bar association over AI hallucinations. On November 11, 2026, the BRAK updated its AI guidance. It states that Section 43 BRAO requires lawyers to independently check every AI output, and that even specialized legal AI hallucinates, if less often.

In Germany, the real penalty often lands on the client: their complaint is ruled inadmissible, as at the BAG, or their appeal fails, as at the KG. That's why lawyers like Jens Ferner point to liability claims against the attorneys.

The Allianz report only partly fits this picture. Allianz Commercial does write that law firms have gotten “into legal trouble” over faulty AI-generated filings. But the report gives no figures specific to law firms. The hard numbers are general: 453 AI incidents in 2025 according to the MIT AI Risk Initiative (2023: 179), and Allianz claims reserves of several million euros.

The bigger picture

The database shows a floor, not a complete count. Charlotin says so himself, and our check for Germany confirms it: the country's two most significant decisions of the year are missing. Three things are established. Laypeople make up the majority of cases. Professionals and government bodies are by no means immune, all the way up to judges and state governments. And sanctions have escalated from symbolic fines to practice bans, now at the European level too.

For Germany, our take is that the low count has three causes. Legal arguments here rely less on cited precedent, hardly any rulings are published, and mandatory representation keeps laypeople out of the higher courts. The BAG shows that things don't have to stop at warnings. There, a filing that clearly nobody reviewed is treated as not coming from a lawyer at all. For clients, that's more expensive than any fine. What remains open is whether the bar associations will eventually step in themselves.

Sources

#ai-hallucinations#judiciary#echr#lawyers#data-analysis#germany

Ask the AI assistant

Questions about this article, installation or background? Our assistant knows this page and runs on our own machine, not in someone else's cloud.

Connecting …

The Assistant is an AI (Gemma 4) and can make mistakes – please check important details against the source. Questions are used only to generate an answer and are deleted after one hour. Please don't enter any personal data.

Comments

What do you think? Already tried it? Write it here, no sign-up needed.

  1. Loading comments …

Comments are public. Links aren't allowed, and we delete abusive posts. You can delete your own comment at any time in this browser. Learn more in the Privacy Policy.