Navier-Stokes, no loophole? Buckmaster and Alpöge claim blowup without external force

Mathematician Tristan Buckmaster and Anthropic researcher Levent Alpöge have published an unfinished proof. It claims that the three-dimensional Navier-Stokes equations can "blow up" in finite time even without an external force. If it holds, it would close the weak spot in OpenAI's disputed September proof. So far, though, nobody has checked it independently.

Research Nov 20, 2026 7 min read Source: Reddit r/singularity
Illustrative image, AI-generated

What's going on

On November 20, 2026, mathematician Tristan Buckmaster of New York University's Courant Institute and Levent Alpöge, a mathematician and researcher at Anthropic, posted a proof online. It claims that the three-dimensional Navier-Stokes equations can develop a "blowup" in finite time without any external force at all. In a blowup, the values of an initially smooth flow become infinite after a finite amount of time. The proof is in the GitHub repository github.com/tristanbuckmaster/navier-stokes. Buckmaster announced it on Mastodon. According to a Reddit post, he describes the proof himself as unpolished, meaning it isn't a finished write-up yet.

On the same day, a claim about a proof of the Riemann hypothesis, another Millennium Problem, also seems to have been making the rounds. The available sources don't say who made it or what exactly it claims. Reddit users in r/singularity mostly point out that both announcements landed on the same day. To be clear: neither claim has been independently verified so far.

What the Navier-Stokes problem is

The Navier-Stokes equations describe how liquids and gases such as water or air move. Essentially, they apply Newton's second law of motion to flows. They're used in aircraft design, weather forecasting and the study of blood flow, among other things. The open problem asks this: if you start with smooth initial conditions, does the solution for an incompressible fluid in three dimensions stay "well-behaved" forever? Incompressible means the fluid can't be squeezed. Or can a singularity form after finite time, a point where, say, the vorticity grows to infinity?

Since 2000, the Clay Mathematics Institute in New York has listed the question as one of its seven Millennium Prize Problems. Each solution is worth $1 million. Before any prize money is paid, though, a proof has to survive several years of rigorous scrutiny.

Mathematician Charles Fefferman wrote the official problem statement and laid out four alternatives. Two of them require proving that smooth solutions always exist: once in unbounded three-dimensional space and once on the three-dimensional torus, a periodic space where you exit on one side and re-enter on the opposite side. The other two require proving that solutions can break down. These versions allow a smooth external force acting on the fluid.

The September dispute

The whole story turns on this distinction. According to the Hindu BusinessLine, Buckmaster and Alpöge spent about a year working on a method developed by mathematicians Diego Córdoba and Luis Martínez-Zoroa. In this approach, a smooth external force drives the fluid into increasingly extreme behavior. On August 15, 2026, they had a breakthrough, heavily assisted by language models such as Anthropic's Claude and OpenAI's Codex and GPT-5.6. By August 22, the result had been verified in the Lean proof assistant. Lean is software that mechanically checks every logical step of a proof. What the two had shown was blowup for the Euler equations, the frictionless special case of Navier-Stokes. According to the student newspaper The Polytechnic, Fields medalist Terence Tao called the result a "remarkable achievement." He said he saw no fundamental obstacle to carrying the method over to Navier-Stokes.

That's exactly what OpenAI then tried. On September 8, the company announced that an internal model, "more capable than GPT-6 Astra," had coordinated 10,000 AI agents in an 88-hour run. The result, it said, was a proof of blowup for the forced Navier-Stokes equations. It covers two of the four Clay alternatives and is formalized in Lean4, checked in 17 hours with GPT-6 Astra. OpenAI doesn't intend to claim the prize because the version it proved is narrower than the full problem.

Buckmaster tells a different story. In a statement, according to Unite.AI, he writes that OpenAI learned about the unpublished work and only then sent the first prompt to the model. During two phone calls on September 6, he says he was first told there had been "very little human input." Over the course of the conversation, however, it emerged that a team had been involved and that the model had first been pointed at simpler problems such as Euler. Buckmaster and Alpöge had kept all of the project's drafts in Codex sessions. When he asked whether the model had been trained on them, he says he got no answer. He was only told that the model doesn't look up user data. He also says Bubeck twice demanded that Alpöge be removed from the author list because of his job at Anthropic. Bubeck calls these accusations "false and inflammatory." According to The Polytechnic, OpenAI says its own work began around September 1 after an unconfirmed rumor. It says it then offered the two a "simultaneous" publication that would have acknowledged their priority on the Euler result.

On September 11, the Clay Institute acknowledged the apparently successful solution of the forced cases. It stressed, however, that the formal prize review is a separate process. 25 living Fields medalists signed a statement criticizing a pattern: AI labs increasingly claiming credit for famous open problems.

What's new now

Many mathematicians saw the external force as a kind of loophole. Formally, it fits the Clay formulation. But it means you can, in a sense, push the fluid into catastrophe from the outside. The physically interesting question is whether a fluid will do that entirely on its own. That's precisely the case the new proof claims to cover: blowup without any external force, with the fluid "exploding" through its own dynamics.

According to Unite.AI, Buckmaster had already hinted in September that he and Alpöge believed they had also found blowup for the "hypo-dissipative" Navier-Stokes equations, a variant with weakened friction. They held that proof back at the time because the Lean check wasn't finished. The available sources don't say whether the new proof is fully formalized in Lean. Calling it an "unpolished" version suggests an early stage.

The role of AI

The duo's earlier work is open about its use of AI. According to Unite.AI, Claude helped identify the core elements of the Córdoba–Martínez-Zoroa proof. Claude and Codex wrote large parts of the text and handled the bookkeeping for constants and induction steps. Models labeled "5.6 Sol" and "Astra" were added later. The quality was sobering at first. Buckmaster called the first AI-generated proof Alpöge sent him "the most horrible one I've ever read." He says the collaboration was purely private, with no involvement from either employer. He paid for the tools, including a hefty OpenAI bill, out of his own research funds. He credits the core ideas to Córdoba and Martínez-Zoroa and says Martínez-Zoroa deserves a Fields Medal.

Analysis

If the proof holds up, it would be a genuine milestone. Blowup without an external force is considered the far more significant case, and it was exactly the point critics raised against OpenAI's result. For now, though, this is a claim that only just went public. There's no independent review and no polished write-up. And apparently there's no completed Lean formalization either; at least the sources don't mention one.

There's also an open issue that The Polytechnic flagged in October: the autoformalization problem. A Lean proof is only as good as the translation of the problem statement into Lean. If the statement is formalized incorrectly, the machine flawlessly verifies the wrong thing. The paper subsequently retracted its claim that OpenAI's solution was undisputed.

Whatever the outcome, the case shows how much AI is already reshaping top-tier mathematics. Results arrive faster. At the same time, it's getting less clear who owns them, how much human work goes into them and how readable the proofs still are. The fact that the same breakthrough is being fought over by two rival AI companies and their employees doesn't make things any simpler.

Sources

#math#navier-stokes#openai#anthropic#proof#lean
Read the original source

Ask the AI assistant

Questions about this article, installation or background? Our assistant knows this page and runs on our own machine, not in someone else's cloud.

Connecting …

The Assistant is an AI (Gemma 4) and can make mistakes – please check important details against the source. Questions are used only to generate an answer and are deleted after one hour. Please don't enter any personal data.

Comments

What do you think? Already tried it? Write it here, no sign-up needed.

  1. Loading comments …

Comments are public. Links aren't allowed, and we delete abusive posts. You can delete your own comment at any time in this browser. Learn more in the Privacy Policy.