Who controls your PC? How Apple, Google and Microsoft rein in rival AI agents
ChatGPT, Gemini, Telegram and Proton want their AI agents to operate your computer. Apple, Google and Microsoft are meanwhile deciding the terms on which that's allowed, and quietly building agents of their own. We go platform by platform to show the path a third-party agent has to take, and what the EU's Digital Markets Act (DMA) changes for users in Germany and across the EU.

What this is about
An AI that clicks, types and operates apps on its own needs sweeping permissions. It has to see your screen, simulate input and often get at your files too. Those permissions come from the operating system, which means from Apple, Google or Microsoft. And all three companies are now building agents of their own. That raises our question: do third-party agents like ChatGPT, Gemini for Mac, Telegram's “Dictator” or Proton Lumo have to take the same path as the in-house ones? And do the new hurdles protect users, or mostly hold back the competition?
The trigger is a week in which all three platforms tightened their rules. On November 16, Apple released the second beta of macOS 27.3 with new agent permissions. Afterwards, according to Bloomberg, word got out that Apple is building its own Mac agent. Google also published Play Store rules for AppFunctions, its agent interface.
macOS: more clicks for outsiders, open questions about the in-house agent
Until now, a third-party agent on the Mac has needed two system permissions. For ChatGPT, according to OpenAI's documentation, these are “Screen Recording,” so the AI can see an app, and “Accessibility,” so it can click and type. Many agents also ask for Full Disk Access. On October 2, Apple announced it would regulate this access more strictly. According to TechCrunch, Apple's reasoning is that some developers were using the permission in ways that exposed everything on the system “without users' full knowledge and understanding.” This followed a report by journalist Jason Aten, who said Meta's agent Muse knew the contents of his private messages. Meta denies this.
According to Apple's developer note, as quoted by MacRumors, macOS 27.3 beta 2 brings the following:
- The existing “Device Control & Data Access” setting is split into two permissions: System & App Protection Override for apps that remote-control other apps, and Accessibility for assistive technology such as screen readers.
- You now grant an agent access only to specific apps or folders, picked from a list: Mail, say, but not Messages.
- You can set an app to ask every time before it accesses anything.
- A menu bar icon shows when one app is controlling another. According to Macworld, you can't hide it in System Settings.
- New warning screens appear. In a screenshot posted by Bloomberg reporter Mark Gurman, one says the Mac can't protect your data from “Codex Computer Use.”
Per Bloomberg, it now takes 14 steps instead of 4 before ChatGPT can control your Mac. According to tbreak, that number applies only to ChatGPT. The warning screens, however, hit every app that requests Full Disk Access. Permissions you've already granted stay in place. Apple says well-known apps remain unchanged for now. Backup tools and assistive apps for people with disabilities can apply for special entitlements. Macworld expects the final update in early to mid-December; there's no official date.
On the other side is the in-house agent. According to The Next Web, Apple this week posted a job listing for a “Senior Engineering Manager, Agentic AI – Proactive.” The role was for an agent that “uses a computer the way a capable human does”: across apps, browsers, the command line, code and APIs. The listing calls for “strong permission models, sandboxing and transparency.” It has since been taken down. Bloomberg puts the earliest possible launch at late 2027. Apple won't say whether this agent will have to clear the same hurdles.
There's already a clue. Federico Viticci of MacStories calls the changes “better than feared.” But he notes that Siri AI has capabilities on par with Full Disk Access “without going through the same approval process,” and doesn't even show up in the Full Disk Access list.
Android: the in-house assistant holds the key
On Android, the question isn't how many clicks it takes, but who gets access at all. With AppFunctions, apps can expose functions like “create task” or “search mail” as tools for agents, much like servers built on the Model Context Protocol (MCP), a kind of universal plug for AI tools. To discover and call functions in other apps, an agent needs the privileged permission EXECUTE_APP_FUNCTIONS, according to the Android developer docs. Android grants it only to “authorized system assistants.” If you want to expose your app's functions to Gemini, you have to apply for a Google developer preview.
The new Play rules take effect on April 14, 2027. They target apps that offer functions. According to Play Console Help, these functions must not deceive agents, return hidden instructions or circumvent safeguards. Nor may they interfere with an agent choosing other apps or services. That protects the agent from manipulated apps. Who gets to be the agent in the first place is something the Play rules don't address.
Windows: a separate workspace and a hidden counter
Microsoft has agents work in an Agent Workspace: a separate Windows session with its own agent account. According to Microsoft Support, the feature is off by default and only an administrator can turn it on. For the six personal folders, each agent gets the options “Always allow,” “Ask every time” and “Never allow.” Tools like File Explorer are hooked up as Agent Connectors via an on-device registry. Microsoft's blog says agents must be “signed by a trusted source.” The docs mostly use Copilot as the example. For other developers, Microsoft announced a private preview in October 2025. Whether third-party agents can get as far as Copilot today isn't clear from the documentation.
Then there's a discovery from November 16. Security researcher Xusheng Li found an undocumented Windows 11 component called CLICodingAgentUsage. It records whether programs like codex.exe, claude.exe, copilot.exe or cursor.exe are running and reports this to Microsoft when optional diagnostic data is turned on. Only yes/no values are sent, and Microsoft's own Copilot is tracked the same way. So it doesn't put third-party agents at a disadvantage. But Microsoft does learn which rival products are running on people's machines.
Side by side: the path for third-party vs. in-house agents
| macOS 27.3 | Android | Windows 11 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Third-party agent needs | Screen Recording, Accessibility, new: App Override, optionally Full Disk Access, warnings | privileged permission that only system assistants get; otherwise a workaround via Accessibility | Agent Workspace (an admin must turn it on), signature, per-folder approval |
| In-house agent | Siri AI not listed under Full Disk Access (per MacStories); Mac agent in the works | Gemini is the authorized assistant | Copilot Actions as the first Workspace user |
| User control | per app/folder, “ask every time,” menu bar icon | system permission settings | Always / Ask / Never per agent |
| EU intervention | none (see below) | DMA decision of July 16, 2026 | no known agent proceedings |
Strikingly, the agents themselves have landed on the same pattern for permissions. Telegram's Dictator offers “Allow, Ask, Never,” according to TestingCatalog, and runs in an isolated Linux VM. Proton Lumo distinguishes between “automatic,” “approval” and “blocked,” with connected tools switched on by default. Gemini only sees “connected folders.” Our take: many makers of third-party agents have built in stricter rules than the system permissions the OS has demanded of them so far.
Protection or roadblock?
The case for protection: Full Disk Access was originally meant for backup software and opens up mail, messages and browser history. A Cloud Security Alliance survey of 228 professionals found that 74 percent say agents get more permissions than they need. 68 percent can't clearly tell agent actions apart from user actions. Signal now blocks screenshots too, so assistants can't read along in chats. The messenger is calling on all three vendors to offer a documented way to exclude apps from AI access. Viticci even believes per-folder permissions could help third-party agents, because cautious users would be more willing to grant them something.
The case for roadblock: Apple justifies the hurdles with security while building its own agent at the same time. According to Longbridge, Gurman expects third-party agents to have a harder time once Apple's product ships. The developer note mentions neither AI nor Siri. Nor does it say whether Apple's own features trigger the same prompts. On Android, Gemini's priority is even hard-coded. Wharton professor Ethan Mollick wrote on X that companies would anger a lot of customers if they banned them from using their own agents. “Fear only works for so long.”
Our take: the individual measures make sense. The problem starts when they only apply to others. The real test is whether Apple's agent goes through the same approval process when it arrives in 2027 or later.
What the DMA actually changes for users in Germany and the EU
Android: On July 16, 2026, the European Commission issued a binding decision on Article 6(7) of the DMA (case DMA.100220). Rival assistants are to get the same access as Gemini, on four levels:
- Invocation: their own wake word, long-pressing the home button
- Context: screen content, app data
- Actions: screen control, control across app boundaries
- Resources: on-device AI models, background execution
Access has to be free and documented. According to the Cloud Security Alliance, most obligations apply from August 1, 2027, with Android 18. Multiple wake words active at the same time won't arrive until 2028. Depending on how you count, eleven or twelve features are covered. For five especially sensitive ones, the assistant needs certification, and Google runs that process. Writing on the Kluwer blog, legal scholar Alba Ribera Martínez argues that this hands discretion back to the gatekeeper. Google filed suit at the EU General Court in September. A lawsuit doesn't automatically suspend the obligations, though.
iPhone: Apple isn't bringing Siri AI to iOS 27 and iPadOS 27 in the EU because of the DMA. According to Apple, the Commission rejected all of its proposals, including a “Trusted System Agent” acting as an intermediary for 18 months. Commission spokesperson Thomas Regnier pushes back:
“The decision not to launch Siri AI in the EU is Apple's decision alone.”
Apple had asked for an exemption, he said, and that is “not an option.” Neither side has given a timeline.
Mac: Here the DMA changes nothing. iOS and iPadOS are designated, macOS isn't. That's why Siri AI is available on the Mac in the EU, and why the macOS 27.3 hurdles apply there unchanged. On top of that, Gemini's Computer Use isn't available in the EEA, according to unite.ai, and neither was Codex Computer Use at launch, per MacRumors. So Mac users in Germany and the rest of the EU get the in-house assistant while some third-party agents are still missing. Part of the reason lies with those vendors themselves, though.
On the legal side, Friso Bostoen and Jan Krämer, writing in the Journal of Competition Law & Economics, call the DMA “surprisingly future-proof.” Agent lock-out happens mainly on mobile operating systems, they argue, and those are already covered. Giuseppe Colangelo of ICLE counters that standalone AI agents could themselves become new gatekeepers that the DMA barely reaches.
Our verdict
All three platforms are giving third-party agents finer-grained permissions and more prompts. That's good for users, and some agent makers have already built similar rules themselves. But the paths are nowhere near equal. On Android, Gemini's priority is hard-coded; on the Mac, it's an open question whether Siri and Apple's future agent will ever see the new warnings. On Windows, it's unclear whether third-party agents can get as far as Copilot today. So far the DMA only bites on Android, and even there not before August 2027, under Google's certification and with a lawsuit pending. For Mac and Windows users in Germany and the EU, the vendors' own rules are all that apply for now. If you grant an agent access today, use the new options: allow only specific folders and apps, and set it to “ask every time.”
Sources
- MacRumors: macOS 27.3 Warns Against Giving AI Apps Full Mac Control macrumors.com
- Habr (Selectel): Что Apple готовит для ИИ-агентов на Mac habr.com
- The Next Web: Apple is building an AI agent that codes and controls apps thenextweb.com
- tbreak: ChatGPT’s Mac setup now takes 14 steps in the macOS 27.3 beta tbreak.com
- Tech Between the Lines: Gemini Can Now Use Your Mac Apps. Apple Is Changing the Rules techbetweenthelines.com
- Longbridge: Apple Forms AI Agent Team; macOS Has Already Set Soft Barriers longbridge.com
- MacStories: macOS 27.3’s Full Disk Access Changes Are Better Than I Feared macstories.net
- Macworld: Apple has a handy new menu bar icon in macOS 27.3 macworld.com
- TechCrunch: Apple tightening macOS Full Disk Access controls due to AI agents techcrunch.com
- 9to5Mac: macOS 27.3 could change how you grant AI agents Full Disk Access 9to5mac.com
- OpenAI/ChatGPT-Doku: Computer Use learn.chatgpt.com
- Play-Console-Hilfe: Vorschau AppFunctions-Richtlinie support.google.com
- Android Developers: AppFunctions developer.android.com
- Codeflamme: Android AppFunctions Play Policy codeflamme.com
- Cloud Security Alliance: EU Mandates System-Level Android Access for Rival AI Assistants labs.cloudsecurityalliance.org
- Kluwer Competition Law Blog: Keeping the Gate legalblogs.wolterskluwer.com
- Android Authority: Google fights EU rules to open up Android AI androidauthority.com
- Apple Newsroom: Due to DMA, Siri AI delayed in EU for iOS 27 and iPadOS 27 apple.com
- Silicon UK: EU Says Apple Asked For 18-Month DMA Exemption silicon.co.uk
- Microsoft Support: Experimental Agentic Features support.microsoft.com
- Windows Blog: Securing AI agents on Windows blogs.windows.com
- Cyber Security News: Windows 11 AI agent tracking cybersecuritynews.com
- ICLE: The DMA Meets the New Intermediaries laweconcenter.org
- Tilburg University: How Future-Proof is the DMA? A Case Study of AI Agents research.tilburguniversity.edu
- Unite.ai: Signal adds screenshot restrictions unite.ai
- TechCrunch: Gemini can use your Mac techcrunch.com
- TestingCatalog: Telegram prepares Dictator AI agent with its own VM on Mac testingcatalog.com
- TechCrunch: Proton’s Lumo arrives on desktop techcrunch.com
- Ethan Mollick auf X x.com
Ask the AI assistant
Questions about this article, installation or background? Our assistant knows this page and runs on our own machine, not in someone else's cloud.
The Assistant is an AI (Gemma 4) and can make mistakes – please check important details against the source. Questions are used only to generate an answer and are deleted after one hour. Please don't enter any personal data.
Comments
What do you think? Already tried it? Write it here, no sign-up needed.
Comments are public. Links aren't allowed, and we delete abusive posts. You can delete your own comment at any time in this browser. Learn more in the Privacy Policy.